The Future of Work Is Flexible: New DOL Rule is a Major Victory for Shoppers

Casey Aden-Wansbury

Casey Aden-Wansbury

CAR_03_01417_JinxFinal.jpg

Over the past five years, I've had countless conversations with Instacart shoppers about why they choose this work. And time and again, one answer comes up: independence and flexibility. Not as a “nice to have,” not as a convenient perk — but as a necessity.

For many, a traditional 9-to-5 job simply doesn’t fit. They may be caregivers. They may be students. They may already have a full-time job and want to earn a little extra on the side. For any number of reasons, they need to build work around their lives, not the other way around.

That's why the Department of Labor's newly finalized independent contractor rule is a big step for hundreds of thousands of shoppers and millions of other independent workers across the United States. This federal rule will help protect the independence of app-based workers, including Instacart shoppers, in an environment where states are taking different approaches to classifying independent work.

We applaud Secretary Keith Sonderling and the Department of Labor for truly listening to workers and taking bold action  to protect independent contractor certainty.

What's Actually Changing

The rules over worker classification have changed from one administration to the next. Until today, the most recent version was open-ended and convoluted, leaving cloudy how, for example, the Department of Labor would evaluate independent contractor status when it comes to enforcement. 

The new rule makes it simpler. It asks two core questions: 

  1. Who's in charge of how the work gets done? 

  2. And can the worker earn more or less depending on their own choices? 

What Shoppers Tell Us

For Instacart shoppers, that's good news. The vast majority tell us they choose Instacart because they can decide when, where, and how much they work, whether that's a few hours around a full-time job, school, or family. In our most recent annual survey, about 75% of shoppers say flexibility is why they choose Instacart, and nearly three in four of those working 20+ hours a week prefer to stay independent. 

Just how much do shoppers value that flexibility? Most shoppers say they would turn down a 50% increase in earnings if it meant they had to give up the ability to choose when to work.

For Rich, a shopper in Colorado, that independence has a deeply personal dimension: "As a dad, the flexibility of my job allows me to spend time with my children. As a son, it allows me to visit my mother in her assisted living home. The freedom to turn on the app and earn income on my own terms means the world to my family and me."

For Monica, a shopper in New York City, shopping supported her retirement and spending time with her family: “I started shopping with Instacart because I retired from working in the medical field over twenty years and needed additional income. Shopping allows me to balance spending time with my two-year-old granddaughter. Losing my flexibility would mean I wouldn't be able to pick the hours that I need.”

That kind of flexibility — true minute-to-minute control over when and where to work — is part of the reason why about 70% of shoppers have other sources of income. And for 80% of those, Instacart is not their primary source of income. Shoppers are parents, caregivers, students, and retirees building work around their lives. That's why a clear, simple rule matters: it lets shoppers keep doing what works for them, when it works for them.

Shopper Voices Made A Difference 

We’ve been proud to advocate to protect independent work for years, calling on leaders at every level of government to recognize the needs of today’s workforce. Of course, the most powerful voices in this process were the independent workers themselves, including Instacart shoppers from all across the country. More than 2,000 shoppers submitted individual comments about why flexibility and independence matters to them.

To every shopper who spoke up: thank you. Your voices made a difference. We'll keep working alongside you to protect the independence and flexibility you consistently tell us you want.

Cutting tomatoes on a cutting board after grocery delivery.
Casey Aden-Wansbury

Casey Aden-Wansbury

Author

Casey Aden-Wansbury is Instacart's Vice President, Head of Global Public Policy, where she leads government relations, public engagement, policy development, research, and social impact for the leading grocery technology company in North America. Named one of the nation’s top lobbyists (National Institute for Lobbying & Ethics), Casey also serves on the boards of the Alliance to End Hunger and Flex. Before Instacart, Casey directed federal affairs at Airbnb, and she previously served for over a decade in the United States Senate, as a chief of staff and communications director.